ALA Booklist

Perfect Lyla Marks signed up to practice her cello in one of the two small rooms available to students during lunch period. No matter that these days the thought of playing her cello makes her so tense she can barely breathe. Lyla has access to the practice room on even-numbered days. On odd-numbered days, the room d the school's battered guitar used by scruffy Tripp Broody. The notes left in the strings of the guitar begin when Lyla complains to Tripp about leaving trash in their shared room, and the conversation continues from there. Like every good Romeo and Juliet story, there is class struggle and tragedy, but the musical focus is what sets this story apart. The couple's exchange of musical ideas is illustrated through scribbled chords, half-conceived lyrics, and brainstorming sessions. Lyla and Tripp's chaste relationship makes this accessible for younger tweens, much in the style of Meg Cabot's Princess Diaries books. Amato is able to combine both light-hearted fiction for the juvenile crowd and poignant, realistic fiction for older readers without sacrificing humor or depth.

Horn Book

Slacker guitarist Tripp and "perfect" cellist Lyla are completely different people. When they begin sharing a band practice room on alternating days they start communicating through (initially) passive aggressive notes. They eventually become friends and combine their talents to make music together. The deus ex machina ending circumvents real resolution, but the interesting premise will likely appeal to musicians.

Kirkus Reviews

Tripp Broody and Lila Marks (Mr. Odd and Ms. Even) alternate lunch-period use of an instrumental practice room and a school guitar, developing a bond through their shared feelings of pressure and their love for making their own music. Lila's deceased mother was a professional cellist. While Lila expects to follow in her footsteps, part of her would like a break from both the cello and a demanding best friend, Annie Win. Playing the guitar helped Tripp forget the death of his father and the absence of his best friend, who moved away, but his mother has confiscated his instrument until his grades improve. It is their developing emotional relationship rather than a physical connection that defines the novel. Short, third-person present-tense vignettes, each headed with a place and date, carry the plot along, helped by frequent emails, text messages and handwritten notes, as well as illustrations (not seen, but said to include music, notes, tests and receipts). The intense drama of the ending surprises after the gradual development of their friendship, but the picture of the myriad pressures teens feel rings true. Amato, also a Washington, D.C.–area songwriter, weaves in convincing musical detail and advice that will appeal especially to readers experimenting with an instrument themselves. This one will resonate. (Fiction. 12-16)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Amato (Edgar Allan-s Official Crime Investigation Notebook) pens a music-driven meet-cute starring two dissimilar high school students. Trip Broody is an observant introvert whose only release is playing guitar. When his mother takes it away from him, in the hopes that he will become more social, he uses a school guitar and practice room, alternating days with Lyla Marks, a talented cellist who is under tremendous external pressure to get into a prestigious conservatory. What begins as an exchange of terse notes between Tripp and Lyla turns into emails and text messages, and soon a close friendship anchored by their shared love of music evolves. Trip encourages Lyla to loosen up, she draws him out of his shell, and they find similarities in their lives and begin to write music together. Amato nicely captures Tripp-s love of music and Lyla-s anxieties, though the story takes a late melodramatic turn that jars with the comparatively light material that precedes it. While the story is notably -clean- (Tripp and Lyla-s relationship is entirely chaste, and there-s no swearing, alcohol, etc.), the characters- chemistry will have readers- hearts racing. Ages 12-up. (July)

School Library Journal

Gr 8 Up-Two very different high school students discover a mutual appreciation for writing songs for the guitar. Tripp Broody has lost a lot; his father died and his best friend moved away. He doesn't really connect with people, especially his nagging mother whose "help" isn't much appreciated. In contrast, Lyla Marks is perfect. She gets good grades, her teachers love her, and she plays the cello beautifully. Things are not perfect, however, as both her best friend and father suffocate her with unrealistic expectations and adulation over her talent. Forced to share a music practice room on alternating days at school, Lyla leaves a heated note one day when Tripp doesn't throw out his trash. This leads to a pen-pal-like exchange daily, and eventually in-person musical collaboration that promises to change both of their lives forever. Many chapters are structured as Tripp's and Lyla's notes, giving readers a unique vantage point into their burgeoning friendship. The teens find kindred spirits in one another, allowing them to develop lyrics for songs they write in a fluid and natural way. While the end of the novel has a bit of contrived tragedy, this is nevertheless a sweet story of two different loners finding their counterpoint. Ryan P. Donovan, New York Public Library