Horn Book

After explaining that witches are actually afraid of humans, a young witch goes in for a closer look. She falls off her broom trying to "trick a tree" and bumps into some Halloween–goers before befriending a girl costumed as a witch. The story is on the slight side, but the watercolor illustrations include playful details, such as a tombstone that reads "Frank N. Stein."

Kirkus Reviews

Witches really do exist, and they live in haunted houses. But most witches have a secret: They are afraid of humans, who, shockingly, do not have green skin. This young witch is very brave, however, and she's done her research, so on Halloween night, to the chagrin of her elders, she sets off to meet a real human and find out if all she has read is true. (According to her book, humans do not wear pointy hats, they don't cackle regularly and they are afraid to fly.) A misheard phrase ("Trick a tree?") and a subsequent tumble from her broom produce a chance meeting with a girl dressed up as a witch, and the two share an unforgettable night during which at least one myth about humans is definitively debunked. This gently humorous story is teamed with appealing, warm, yet appropriately spooky watercolors that depict the very brave witch on what is, naturally, her favorite holiday. (Picture book. 3-6)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

You might not believe this, but most witches are afraid of humans," a witch girl confides. As her encyclopedic <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">Big Book of Humans indicates, "Humans aren't green like us," and they often dislike flying. Consequently, older witches tremble when she takes a Halloween risk and offers a human girl a broom ride. McGhee and Bliss (previously paired for <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">Countdown to Kindergarten) take a witty, sideways approach to multicultural crossover; the parental demographic might chuckle at headstones labeled Addams and Joey Ramone. Bliss channels Charles M. Schulz in his voice-bubble dialogue and expressive drawings of children with circular heads, simple mouths and dot-eyes with parentheses-shaped eyelids. Like Michael Rex's <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">Brooms Are for Flying! and David Costello's <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">Here They Come!, this tale demystifies the amiable protagonist and her non-green counterpart alike. Ages 4-8. <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">(Aug.)

School Library Journal

K-Gr 2-A friendly young witch describes what she likes most about Halloween. She explains that although most of her kind "-are afraid of humans," she has done research and concluded that people are not that bad. She plans to visit them this Halloween night as they "trick a tree." After boarding her broom, she zooms in a circle, becomes dizzy, and crashes near some trick-or-treaters. She soon discovers that a brave witch and a brave human girl dressed as a witch are not so very different. As the book ends, the two new friends share a moonlit broomstick ride. The chatty text appears in dialogue balloons. Done in black ink and watercolor, the cartoon artwork captures the holiday's spirit with crisp fall colors and amusing details. Busy witches decorate their creepy-looking mansion by hanging skeletons, un-caging bats, and sprinkling spiders out the windows. In the "Sub-Basement Costume Unit," a seamstress is hard at work sewing a monster paw; costumes line the walls (Frankenstein, a space creature, etc.); and politician masks share space with a jar full of eyeballs. Both children-one green and one not-are appealing, and the witch's orange cat, with its expressive features, adds to the fun. A humorous, not-scary-at-all read-aloud.-Wanda Meyers-Hines, Ridgecrest Elementary School, Huntsville, AL Copyright 2006 Reed Business Information.