Publisher's Hardcover ©2019 | -- |
Paperback ©2020 | -- |
Imaginary companions. Juvenile fiction.
Best friends. Juvenile fiction.
Friendship. Juvenile fiction.
Magic. Juvenile fiction.
Imagination. Juvenile fiction.
Fathers and daughters. Juvenile fiction.
Children of cancer patients. Juvenile fiction.
Imaginary playmates. Fiction.
Best friends. Fiction.
Friendship. Fiction.
Magic. Fiction.
Imagination. Fiction.
Fathers and daughters. Fiction.
Cancer. Fiction.
After Jade's dad was diagnosed with cancer, her family canceled the plan to move away from their small Colorado town, and so Jade has been stuck there while the town gets smaller and her friends move away. In order to cope with the worry over her father's illness, Jade turns to writing, and she ends up creating her own perfect friend in Zoe, a character who never leaves and does everything with Jade. When a classmate discovers magic in the town's pond, however, he uses it to bring Zoe to life, and soon Jade discovers that it's not always easy having a perfect best friend and that life is much more complicated than fiction. Her father's illness and the surrounding drama are handled nicely as Jade's family comes together and she realizes what she's been missing out on by not being fully present. An endearing story, with a pitch-perfect tween voice and a touch of magic, about what makes a friend.
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)In this lightly fantastical tale, sixth grader Jade has a history of losing best friends. People don-t stay in her tiny Colorado town for long, so to fight lunchroom loneliness and science-class boredom, Jade writes stories in a big yellow notebook about her ideal best friend, a charismatic girl named Zoe, with whom she shares private jokes and secrets. When a classmate, nicknamed Clue, steals her notebook and promises -a big surprise,- Jade is initially furious, but her curiosity wins out, and she agrees to wait for Clue-s big revelation. Then, a girl exactly matching Zoe-s qualities moves in across the street, and an astonished Jade must rely on her storytelling abilities as never before: since the fictional character only knows what has written about her, Jade must keep adding to her stories to avoid attracting suspicion. Cooper (
Gr 3-5 -In Jade's Colorado town, people are always moving in and out. She's had best friends and lost them, and she's finally decided that the best way to keep a friend is to write one for herself. Zoe is everything she could ever want in a best friend, and their exploits are legendaryin Jade's mind, at least. But when Zoe is brought to life by a quirky classmate and some magical pond water, Jade must deal with the day-to-day realities of having a formerly fictional best friend. At first, Zoe is content to be constantly guided by Jade. But is it real friendship when Zoe lacks agency? And is Jade neglecting other people in her life to devote all her time to perfecting her friendship with Zoe? Readers who also enjoy the craft of writing will find plenty to like here. Since Jade is an aspiring writer, there are plenty of writing tips, usually offered by Jade's favorite teacher Mrs. Yang. VERDICT This contemplative fantasy has plenty of character development and touches of magical realism. Offer to fans of Kate Messner and Sarah Weeks.-Misti Tidman, Mansfield/Richland County Public Library, OH
ALA Booklist (Sun Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)
Coretta Scott King Honor (Sun Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
School Library Journal (Sun Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)
OPPSERVATION: You can love something but not really like it very much.
Questions for further research: Why, lunchtime, why?
I tucked my oppservation journal into my bag and scanned the cafeteria. This was supposed to be the best part of the day. At least for most people it was. Most people grabbed their lunches as fast as they could and went to their tables with their best friends to laugh and talk and make plans for after school. Most people got to forget about anything bad and just relax and hang out and eat.
Sometimes, during the time it took me to get my brown bag out of my locker and sit at my table, I got sad.
But then, once I sat down, I remembered. I was going to have lunch with my best friend, too, just like everybody else. Only my best friend wasn't like anyone else's. She was better.
I sat in my usual spot, took out my cheese sandwich and my yellow notebook, and waited. Sometimes she showed up right away. Other times she took a little longer. Today must have been one of those other times, because it felt like she was taking forever.
I thought about what we might do when she finally got here. After eating, maybe we'd share my headphones and listen to music the way Nia and Zara always do. Or maybe we'd purposely give ourselves milk mustaches and take really funny selfies like Molly and Casey do. We could even do some things that other people around here couldn't, too, like make plans for the weekend. And next weekend. And next year. People in Tiveda, Colorado moved away all the time. I've heard adults call this place a transient town, which must mean it's not good enough to stay, or something, because you never really knew who would be at school on Monday and who would've moved on to a new town. But Zoe was always a sure thing. Not only did we have today together, we had all our tomorrows too.
Still, there was a pang deep down in the pit of my stomach as I watched everybody else having fun. For a second I thought Nia and Zara were going to invite me to come sit with them, but then they looked away. I frowned at my notebook. What was taking Zoe so long?
Mrs. Yang, my English teacher, always says that the hardest part is starting. No matter how long you've been writing or how much you love it, she says, sometimes the blank page can be the scariest thing there is. She says that you should just put a word on it. Any word. Then put another one.
I opened my notebook.
Zoe and Jade and the Best Lunch Ever, I wrote at the top. Eight words! Take that, blank page.
I stopped staring at Nia and Zara and Molly and Casey. I took a deep breath. I wrote more. I took a bite of sandwich. I kept going until the warning bell rang, and when it did, I barely even noticed. In my story Zoe and I had just finished taking our milk mustache selfies and now we were making origami napkin birds for each other. She was drawing funny faces on them and pretending hers were talking, and I was trying to make mine talk back but I couldn't because I was laughing too hard.
When I finally closed my notebook and gathered my stuff, I noticed all the faces looking my way. As bad as blank pages were, blank stares were even worse. My pale skin felt as red as my hair. Yeah, I wrote during lunch. So what? It was pretty obvious by the looks I got that people thought it was weird that my nose was always buried in my notebook. But the one thing they never did was ask.
That was fine, though. I didn't want to tell anybody what I was writing anyway. Out of the corner of my eye, I peeked at Gresham Gorham--or Clue, as everybody called him. It was bad enough that he knew my secret.
As if he could feel me looking, Clue turned and stared me right in the face. His dark, serious eyes dropped to my notebook. Then they flashed back to the one in his lap.
My heartbeat quickened, so I took a few long breaths. I pushed my purple glasses up higher on my nose and hugged my notebook to my chest. That calmed me down right away, same as it always did. Forget Clue. Forget other people. Forget everything.
I had Zoe.
And that was all that mattered.
Chapter 2: The Beginning of Zoe
When I started fourth grade my best friend was Joslin. We'd just moved from Nevada and she'd introduced herself to me right away and everything was awesome. She taught me how to play tetherball without getting hit in the face, and we had nine amazing days of not-getting-hit-in-the-face best-friend fun.
Then she moved away, and I never heard from her again. I kept sending letters, and she kept not writing back.
So then I hung out with Rosie. Rosie liked to write, like me.
But not enough, I guess. After she moved she didn't write letters or emails or postcards like she promised she would. Not even one. And no texts either. But I guess I can't blame her, because I was still the only kid in my grade (and the world, it felt like) who didn't have a cell phone.
I hadn't been in Tiveda for that long, but I was already sick of people coming and going so much. People only lived here so they could feel like they were living in Denver, even though they weren't living in Denver. When they could afford something nicer (usually in Denver), they left.
Sometimes, if they couldn't afford something nicer--or if they couldn't even afford it here--they'd move further down the road, to Bertsburg, where everyone lived in trailers. It wasn't far away, but far enough where the people who lived there went to another school, which may as well have been a whole different universe.
Dad always compared Tiveda to those rest stops in random places off the highway. People pulled over when they needed to stretch their legs, to have a bathroom break and a snack, and then they took off. That's what we were supposed to do while Mom painted murals in buildings around town and Dad consulted with an energy company, whatever that meant.
But instead of a stretch and a snack, we stayed in Tiveda for a full night of sleep and a full day of meals. Over and over and over again. As U-Hauls pulled in and pulled out, we stayed right where we were. And now we were officially stuck in a town that had a different mailman every other day, three stores that were considered the mall, and zero flowers because whenever anybody planted some, they left when the seeds needed care the most.
In my opinion you should be able to know the name of the person delivering your mail. Three stores did not make a mall. And was it really that hard to stay long enough for a flower to bloom?
Because of all this, I was about to give up on ever having a best friend when Vanessa joined my always- changing little class toward the end of fourth grade. Her smile was warm and friendly. Plus she had a giant collection of candles that she really wanted to show off, and I really wanted to see something besides all my own junk. She invited me over right away, and soon we had an after-school tradition every day--to just hang out. Sometimes we'd spend hours lining up the candles from favorite to least favorite. Or most smelly to least smelly. Or tallest to shortest. We never ran out of ways.
Nessa was planning a gigantic birthday party--well, as gigantic as you could get around here--and I helped her get everything ready. It was going to be at one of those places where the whole room was a big trampoline. I had never been to a place like that before, and it sounded totally amazing. And it was only fifteen minutes away, so maybe we could go back sometime. Every day after school we would cross a day off her cute dog calendar. Everything was about jumping and candles and best-friend fun. Everything was fun at home too. Dad was happy. Mom was happy. My little brother Bo was only three, so he was extra cute and hilarious. We were supposed to move soon, too, to a more forever kind of place in Denver. Maybe we'd even get a dog.
So that's why it was a pretty big surprise when Mom and Bo picked me up from the birthday party five minutes after Nessa's parents brought us there.
"We have to go to the hospital," Mom said in a loud, scared voice, the kind that made all the trampoline-jumping people stop and stare.
I hadn't even finished taking off my shoes. "Why?" I asked. "What's going on?"
"I'll explain in the car," she said. "Go say goodbye to your friends."
Somehow I made my way over to Nessa, even though my legs felt like noodles and my stomach had leapt to my throat.
"I have to go," I said. My voice barely eked out. "I don't know why."
Nessa made a face like she'd just taken a bite of birthday cake, only to discover it was really a sour lemon. "What do you mean?"
I couldn't see Mom from where I was standing, but I could definitely hear her foot tapping by the door. Let's go, the taps said. They came faster and louder. Let's gooooooooo!
"My mom says I have to," I told Nessa. "Something about the hospital."
Cold air blasted through the room. Nessa frowned. "I don't get it."
I swallowed hard. I felt ice-sculpture frozen.
"Me either."
I waited for her to give me a hug or tell me to call her later or something, because we were best friends, and I obviously didn't want to go, and my leaving was bugging both of us and freaking us both out.
But she didn't do any of that. Instead she crossed her arms and said, "Best friends do not miss each other's parties."
"I know!" My voice switched from shaky to shrieky. "I don't want to! But--"
"Jade," Mom called. "Now, please."
My body tensed. It felt like everyone there was jumping on my heart like it was one of the trampolines.
"I--" I couldn't find the right words. I couldn't find any words, period. And it didn't matter anyway. Because Nessa--my very best friend in the whole world--had walked away.
Leaving the party barely felt real. Neither did getting in the car, putting on my seatbelt, or driving to the hospital.
Mom said a lot of words in the car, but they all blurred together. Sick. Dad. Tests. Urgent. Sickdadtestsurgent. They sounded like one big, blobby word, and my heart felt like a big, blobby mess.
How was it possible that your whole family could be so happy, and everything could be going so well, and you could even be thinking about getting a dog, and then, just like that, you weren't?
And how could a best friend who's supposed to care about you not understand that something bad was happening, and leaving her party wasn't your choice?
When we got to the hospital, Dad was taking a test that we couldn't help with, so we went to the gift shop instead of to his room. Bo got a sketch pad and crayons and I got the biggest yellow notebook I'd ever seen in my life. Mom looked pretty happy about that. She knew how fast I could fill a regular-sized notebook. There were tons of them piled up in my room already. When you want to be an author someday, you have to practice a lot.
On the first page of the notebook, I wrote some of the things I'd been thinking about in the car on the way over. I put Oppservationsat the top. This was the beginning of my list of observations about something opposite, like how your best friend could suddenly become not so friendly when you did something she didn't like, even if it wasn't your fault.
On the next page, I started writing a story. About me and Nessa and trampolines and how things should have gone.
Dad should have been fine. I should have gotten to stay at the party. We should have had the best time ever. Joslin and Rosie should have written to me to apologize for not staying in touch. If I couldn't stay at the party, and Dad wasn't fine, then all my friends, especially Nessa, should have come to the hospital with me. Or called to check on things, or promised to come by later with leftover cake.
Or waved.
Or something.
Maybe Nessa wasn't the perfect best friend, even though we always had fun together. And Rosie and Joslin definitely weren't the perfect best friend, because they left me, and they didn't keep in touch, even when I tried to.
I turned the page and started a new story.
Maybe there wasn't a perfect best friend out there for me. Maybe I'd be better off if I created my own.
So instead of writing the names of anyone I knew, I wrote the name Zoe.
Excerpted from Friend or Fiction by Abby Cooper
All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.
One creative middle-schooler discovers that the best friend a girl can have is the one she makes herself in this charming magical realism read.
Jade's life hasn't exactly been normal lately, especially since her dad's cancer diagnosis. Jade wishes her family could leave their no-name town in Colorado already--everybody else does sooner rather than later, including every best friend Jade's ever had. So she makes one up. In the pages of her notebook, she writes all about Zoe--the most amazing best friend anyone could dream of.
But when pretend Zoe appears in real life thanks to a magical experiment gone right, Jade isn't so sure if she likes sharing her imaginary friend with the real world. To keep her best friend (and even make some new ones), Jade learns how to cope with jealousy, that friends should let friends be true to themselves, and that maybe the perfect best friend doesn't exist after all.