Gr 9 Up-An endearing and heartwarming narrative that is realistic and reflective. Kyle and Gideon have happily been best friends and next-door neighbors for much of their lives. However, Gideon unexpectedly develops romantic feelings for Kyle but is unsure as to how to proceed because Kyle is currently in a long-term relationship with Ruby. Told from each character's first-person perspective, the novel presents the complicated process of self-discovery, social acceptance, and, ultimately, love. Readers follow Kyle, Gideon, and Ruby as they attempt to navigate unfamiliar terrain that could jeopardize their current relationships. Those who appreciate strong male protagonists who are quirky, queer, or questioning will enjoy this stand-alone title with broad appeal. Hall expertly captures the nuances of LGBTQ life in an authentic and positive manner. Themes such as honesty, trust, logic, and love are explored throughout. The characters are likable, and their emotions are sure to resonate with readers. Read-alikes include Stephen Chbosky's The Perks of Being a Wallflower , David Levithan and John Green's Will Grayson, Will Grayson , and Jaye Robin Brown's Georgia Peaches and Other Forbidden Fruit . VERDICT This coming-of-age drama of discovering love in unlikely places is tender, accessible, and recommended for most library collections. Katie Flynn, Williston Northampton School Library, MA

Seventeen-year-olds Gideon and Kyle are neighbors and best friends. Gideon is an overachieving nerd, while Kyle is a star basketball player (though, given that he knows Elvish, also a bit of a nerd) with an undiagnosed learning disability. Kyle is "out" to a few select peoplehe is bisexualbut not to one important person: his girlfriend, head cheerleader Ruby. When he comes out, she is cool with it but is less cool when she finds out that Gideon, who up until recently had not realized he was gay, is in love with Kyle. In classic Gideon style, he makes pro/con lists about Kyle, which Ruby discovers. While Gideon wonders if maybe Kyle could like him back, he creates some distance in their relationship, unsure what Ruby intends to do with the damning list. Before long, the boys are dating, but the list's reappearance complicates their burgeoning relationship and their long friendship.This light romance is thin on plot but heavy on cuteness. The premise is charming, but much of the execution works against the book: there are too many points of view (fouronly Gideon's and Kyle's seem necessary) with indistinct voices; the predictable plot is rushed; and Ruby's subplots seem tacked on and underdeveloped. The positive depictions of bisexual and gay teens coming out, being accepted and supported by their friends and families, and getting a happy ending are what make this book an important, if not exceedingly well-written, addition to all teen library collections.Amanda MacGregor.