ALA Booklist
(Tue Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2016)
Four middle-schoolers on a field trip to the National Air and Space Museum stumble onto a shocking surprise e museum has no airplanes. At least, not any more. History has been changed, and the four kids must travel back in time to witness a pivotal moment in the history of air travel and make sure it goes the way it's supposed to. As this is the first of the Smithsonian Institution's new graphic novel series, it should come as no surprise that hefty helpings of historical fact are integrated into the story in the form of characters and events, along with a final page of deeper historical detail. Happily, the information is relevant and interesting (do you know, for instance, the names of the Wright Brothers' two major rivals and the sorts of airship prototypes they developed?) and painlessly included in a brisk adventure. The crisp art, filled with enjoyable historical detail, also helps to bring out the fun in the education. Some questions are cleverly left dangling to pave the way for further adventures.
Publishers Weekly
(Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
First in the Secret Smithsonian Adventures series, this time-bending graphic novel sends a racially diverse quartet of middle school students into the past to fix a corrupted timeline. Not long after Eric, Josephine, Dominique, and Ajay win a trip to the Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum, an inexplicable time shift erases the museum's airplanes, replacing them with dirigibles. A secretive museum guide transports the children back to October 1909, when rival pilots, including Wilbur Wright, were showing off their flying machines as part of the Hudson-Fulton Celebration in New York City. Holographic disguises help the kids blend in, but they soon attract attention as they attempt to stop mysterious adversaries attempting to sabotage Wilbur's flight. Hockensmith (the Nick and Tesla series) and newcomer Kientz supply a fast-moving story full of banter and one-liners, with details drawn from aviation history (a closing page helps set the record straight). Reminiscent of storyboard art, Nielsen's illustrations can look a bit sketchlike and muddied in places, but he does an adept job of conjuring up the story's historical setting and futuristic tech. Ages 9-12. Authors' agent: Josh Getzler, Hannigan Salky Getzler Agency. (Feb.)
School Library Journal
(Tue Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2016)
Gr 3-5 A fun and action-packed exploration of aviation. Eric, Dominique, Ajay, and Josephine are the four winners of their school's science fair and are excited for their field trip to the Smithsonian's National Air and Space Museum. When they get there, they all feel sick, and after they recover, they realize that the museum's planes have been replaced with massive balloon structures with the insignia "Barris Air." They meet Al, the only one who acknowledges the change. Al gives the group talking bracelets that provide historical context and sends them back to 1909 to the Hudson-Fulton Celebration in New York City. The kids realize that something is amiss and follow the people they think are behind the time line shift. They discover that these men, the Barrises, are using holographic disguises to change history and become wealthy in the future. It's up to the four of them to save the day. This is a fast-paced, light read filled with information about the history of flight. Students will also learn about Orville and Wilbur Wright's sister, Katharine Wright, whose contributions have often gone unmentioned, as well as other pilots of the time. The paneling is neat and organized, but the speech bubbles can get confusing. Some pages are too crowded with people or text, and the bubbles overlap. Still, the narrative is edifying and humorous, and there is diversity among main and background characters. Back matter offers more material about the Hudson-Fulton Celebration. VERDICT A fun start to what should be an engaging and enlightening series. Kristyn Dorfman, The Packer Collegiate Institute, Brooklyn, NY