ALA Booklist
Elanor is an Orphan, stolen from her parents and forced to serve the Wicked Queen. But now she is free and fighting against the queen and her huntsmen, while closely hiding a dark secret from the other Orphans. Sussman's companion to Stray (2014) moves away from lost Princess Aislynn to focus on robust, capable Elanor. Though the world Sussman built will confuse new readers, fans will love having more action, more delicate touches of fairy tales, more romance, and a resolution that leads towards a final showdown in the next volume. A solid girl-positive (and sex-positive) addition to fantasy collections.
Horn Book
In the companion to Stray, Elanor has rejoined the orphan rebel group with whom she plots to remove wicked Queen Josetta, who stole her from her parents and enslaved her as a child. This fairy-tale adventure, with a tough rebel warrior heroine wrestling with secrecy and guilt, builds steadily to a conclusion open enough for further episodes in this fantasy world.
School Library Journal
Gr 8 Up-This fantasy is a companion to Stray (HarperCollins, 2014), but stands alone. In this world, magic powers mean everything and only women have them. No one has more magical abilities than the evil Queen Josetta. Pitted against villainous Josetta is our heroine Elanora rebel warrior who has had to rely on her cunning and substantial physical prowess since her magic was forcefully taken from her by the wicked Queen. Elanor and the other rebels embark on a raid designed to weaken the Queen's army and, in the course of battle, become unwittingly burdened with a fatally wounded soldier named Matthias. As Matthias slowly recovers (through magical healing) at the rebel camp, Elanor tries to resist the mutual attraction she and the injured boy share. Instead, Elanor helps train Matthias to fight. A mission to invade the castle goes wrong, and a secret about Matthias is revealed, which changes everything. Once again, Sussman offers a fun, fast-paced adventurous fantasy with strong female characters, off-beat romance, well-portrayed LGBTQIA characters, and a delicious recipeall of which tie in neatly to the story. There is resolution to Elanor's story at the conclusion, but clearly Sussman has more to write about this world. VERDICT Fantasy fans of Kristin Cashore and Rae Carson's books will devour this volume. Tara Kehoe, New Jersey State Library Talking Book and Braille Center, Trenton