Starred Review ALA Booklist (Sun May 01 00:00:00 CDT 2016)

Starred Review After finking on their gang leader and skipping town, redheaded twins Alex and Cleo plan to con a wealthy forty-niner in San Francisco who placed an ad in the paper looking for his long-lost ginger-haired twin boys. Alex and Cleo (after she gets a boyish haircut, naturally) think their plan is a piece of cake, until they meet another pair of red-haired twins win and Silas their way to San Francisco, hoping to pull the same hustle. But that's the least of their problems: the gang leader is after them, with the help of some pirates interested in the heirlooms left to the twins by their mother. In their escape, the foursome get separated: Alex and Edwin get shanghaied on a ship headed around the Horn, while Cleo and Silas stow away on a boat headed to Panama. Mock's luminous full-color artwork beautifully showcases the late-nineteenth-century locations, swashbuckling pirate battles, and jungle treks, all while effortlessly distinguishing among characters (no small feat, given the expansive, diverse cast and two sets of twins). Meanwhile, Larson, befitting the seafaring adventure, keeps the pace clipping along with frequent scene breaks and propulsive reveals. Thankfully, the twins all reunite in San Francisco, but a bevy of remaining mysteries guarantee a sequel. A gorgeously executed, lively caper.

Kirkus Reviews

Two sets of twins find themselves pursued by gangs and pirates on a swashbuckling sea adventure.In mid-19th-century Manhattan, white, carrot-topped 12-year-old twins Cleopatra and Alexander Dodge have taken up with the no-good Black Hook gang since their father's gone missing. When they bumble one of their break-ins, they end up snitching on the gang to save their own skins. Exiled from New York, they decide to head west. On their way, they encounter another set of white, titian-tressed con-artist twins, Silas and Edwin. After a destructive melee, the two sets of twins are separated, and Silas and Cleo (now disguised as a boy and going by Pat) must track down the shanghaied Edwin and Alex. All are being pursued by the Black Hooks and a fierce pirate, who is seeking items carried by Cleo and Alex. With a keen eye to detail and deft pacing, Larson has created a sweeping and richly woven tale that never once loses its breakneck momentum and adroitly juggles a number of themes and plotlines. Mock's clearly delineated panels and earth-toned art breathe life into the historical setting, although some readers may have a hard time distinguishing between the mismatched, similarly dressed sets of identical-looking twins, especially on their sea adventures. The vast cast of secondary characters appropriately includes people of color.Complex, engaging, and sure to please a wide audience. (Graphic historical adventure. 8-13)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Hot-tempered Alex and thoughtful Cleo are pretty sure that their father is dead. Armed only with the watch and knife he left them, the Dodge twins are on their own in an antebellum world of crime and double-dealing. If they can get to San Francisco, they plan to pass as a pair of lost redheaded twins for whom a reward has been offered. To their astonishment, they meet Silas and Edwin, an older set of redheaded twins doing the same thing. (-We expected to meet all kinds of people,- Cleo tells them, -but never ourselves.-) Separated, Alex and Edwin round Cape Horn on a ship, while Cleo and Silas travel through Panama. Larson-s (Who Is AC?) concoction of tried-and-true adventure elements-stowaways, pirate raids, jungle tribes-hangs together convincingly, and scene-stealers such as Tarboro, a free black man who-s a brilliant swordsman and the story-s true hero, provide moral ballast. Illustrator Mock, making her debut, adeptly captures the changing relationships between the twins-especially the gender-bending awkwardness that accompanies Cleo-s stint as a boy. A sequel is promised (so the knife and watch can reveal their secrets). Ages 10-12. (June)