ALA Booklist (Thu Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2012)

In this sequel to Dark Eden (2011), the seven teenagers who were cured of their intense and crippling fears at an isolated site, where doctors conducted experiments with mind control, find themselves returning there in an attempt to see the dying Mrs. Goring, who presides over the creepy property. When she promises them a fix for the physical ailments they mysteriously contracted during their first stay, they wind up in an underground silo, booby-trapped with radioactive waste and worse. Their quest requires them to split up, providing the narrative with plenty of excuses to jump from one scene of action to the next. Readers seeking nonstop plotting will eat this up and revel in the twists and turns of newly exposed facts about the evil director of Eden. The story is told by Will Besting, who alone of the seven is privy to several crucial secrets. Most of the characters fit certain types tion-oriented athlete, smart-aleck alpha girl, weak link, and so on d lack depth. But Carman's fans won't mind since he delivers the cinematic adventure goods. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Heavy online promotion will be highlighted by the immersive multimedia app, which allows users to read the story while unlocking audio and visual bonuses.

Horn Book (Wed Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2012)

One year after escaping Fort Eden, old Mrs. Goring cons Will Besting and the other characters from Dark Eden into coming back. Promising to return what was lost and cure their ailments, Goring sends the teenagers to find some mysterious vials. Despite the strong first-person narration, the plot is confusing if startlingly reminiscent of the prior book.

School Library Journal (Tue May 01 00:00:00 CDT 2012)

Gr 5 Up-In this follow-up to Dark Eden (HarperCollins, 2011), Will Besting returns to Fort Eden at the behest of cranky old Mrs. Goring. Threatening to reveal secrets that could jeopardize Will's relationship with Marisa, the woman pushes her advantage and convinces Will to lure all of Rainsford's former victims back to the abandoned military installation where they were all "cured." Now suffering from inexplicable and debilitating side effects, the kids are promised what they desire most from Goring: a true cure that will return them to 100 percent normal. Sent to the depths of the base to retrieve mysterious vials that hold the key to their salvation, Will begins to suspect Goring's motives when she locks them all inside. To his horror, he discovers that Rainsford and the missing wayward member of their group, Avery, are locked beneath Fort Eden as well. While much of the ominous atmosphere is maintained from the first book, this sequel fails to provide the same high-stakes eeriness of the original. Carman's descriptions of the underground labyrinth where most of the story is set tend to be more confusing than evocative, and the fact that Rainsford and Avery pop up halfway through the novel with no explanation of how or why they got there may baffle many readers. Still, fans of the original will no doubt enjoy this book, which satisfyingly concludes Rainsford's wicked hold over his seven original victims. Ryan Donovan, New York Public Library