Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)

Following Penny and Her Song (2012), Henkes delivers an even stronger slice of anthropomorphic mouse life for beginning readers. The story opens with Penny chatting amicably with her mother in the garden. Penny smells the roses while Mama weeds, and then the mailman delivers a package from Gram. Inside is a doll for Penny, with a note reading, "I saw this doll when I was shopping. I thought you would love her. I hope you will." And, she does. The fly in the ointment is Penny's struggle to name the doll. Her parents make suggestions, but none seem right, and they reassure her, "Try not to think too hard…Then maybe a name will come to you." Sure enough, after taking her doll on a tour of the house and then into the garden, the perfect name arises: "[T]his is Rose!" she announces. Henkes always excels at choosing just-right names for his characters (see Chester, Wilson, Lilly, Sheila Rae and, of course, Chrysanthemum and her "absolutely perfect" moniker), so this story seems particularly at home in his oeuvre. The familiarity of Henkes' mouse world, as well as expertly paced and controlled storytelling for new readers, mark this as a new classic, earning Penny a firm place alongside the not-so-creatively-named Frog, Toad, Little Bear and that celebrated Cat in the Hat. A doll of a beginning reader. (Early reader. 5-7)

Horn Book (Mon Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2013)

Gram sends mouse Penny (Penny and Her Song) a doll, and Penny spends three brief and accessible chapters on the serious business of naming her. The illustrations support the text and also add some character development. Henkes again offers a fine story, memorable characters, and a chance to puzzle through a universal childhood experience alongside a sympathetic protagonist.

School Library Journal Starred Review (Mon Oct 01 00:00:00 CDT 2012)

PreS-Gr 1 The engaging mouse introduced in Penny and Her Song (HarperCollins, 2011) is back. This time she and her mother are working in the garden when the mailman arrives with a package. Penny's grandmother has sent her a doll. She loves it and shows it to her siblings and her father. However, she is stumped because she cannot think of a name for her. After Penny decides to show her doll all around her home, she is inspired to find a name for her in the garden, and she happily runs in and announces her choice to her family. The garden motif is carried throughout the book by the color scheme and the floral wallpaper in the home. Penny's voice is authentic, and her play and interaction with her doll will be recognizable to children. The sight words and repetition are perfect for emerging readers and will allow children to move from being read to toward reading on their own. As supremely satisfying as a Henkes picture book, this beginning reader belongs in collections everywhere.— Stacy Dillon, LREI, New York City

Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews (Thu Apr 28 00:00:00 CDT 2022)

Following Penny and Her Song (2012), Henkes delivers an even stronger slice of anthropomorphic mouse life for beginning readers. The story opens with Penny chatting amicably with her mother in the garden. Penny smells the roses while Mama weeds, and then the mailman delivers a package from Gram. Inside is a doll for Penny, with a note reading, "I saw this doll when I was shopping. I thought you would love her. I hope you will." And, she does. The fly in the ointment is Penny's struggle to name the doll. Her parents make suggestions, but none seem right, and they reassure her, "Try not to think too hard…Then maybe a name will come to you." Sure enough, after taking her doll on a tour of the house and then into the garden, the perfect name arises: "[T]his is Rose!" she announces. Henkes always excels at choosing just-right names for his characters (see Chester, Wilson, Lilly, Sheila Rae and, of course, Chrysanthemum and her "absolutely perfect" moniker), so this story seems particularly at home in his oeuvre. The familiarity of Henkes' mouse world, as well as expertly paced and controlled storytelling for new readers, mark this as a new classic, earning Penny a firm place alongside the not-so-creatively-named Frog, Toad, Little Bear and that celebrated Cat in the Hat. A doll of a beginning reader. (Early reader. 5-7)

ALA Booklist (Sat Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2012)

Mouse girl Penny and her mama are weeding the garden. Well, Mama is weeding; Penny is smelling the roses. When the mailman drops off a box from Gram excitement ensues, and there's no disappointment when the box is opened and an adorable doll with pink cheeks, a pink bow, and a pink dress is revealed. The rest of the story follows Penny as she tries to come up with a name for the new dolly. It's not the most exciting premise, and alert readers may come up with the name before Penny does. But as is so often the case in Henkes stories, what captures attention is the reality of children's emotions and the warmth that family interactions can engender. And of course, there's that sweet, satisfying artwork. Penny is not a feisty heroine like Lily; instead, as depicted in the full-page paintings and vignettes, she has a sweetness to her that will connect with many new readers. The simple story is just right for those starting out. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Henkes' name sells books, and the Penny series of early readers opens a new market for him.

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Penny the mouse, who eagerly awaited the opportunity to sing for her busy family in Penny and Her Song, is delighted to receive a doll from her grandmother (-I love her already,- Penny tells her mother and father separately). But Penny faces a quandary when it comes to naming her doll. As her mother and father attend to -the babies,- they offer suggestions, but nothing feels right until Penny stops thinking so hard and lets the name come to her. While the emotional stakes aren-t quite as high in this sequel, the dynamics between Penny and her parents are spot-on, both in Henkes-s pared-down prose and his delicate watercolor-and-ink scenes. Ages 4-8. (Aug.)