ALA Booklist
(Thu Nov 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)
A companion to Sister Wife (2008), Hrdlitschka's book about a polygamous community, this looks at the life of a teenage boy who leaves. Jon has been kissing Celeste (the heroine of Sister Wife), and he struggles with the Prophet's rules. With the help of a young man who has successfully made the transition into the "gentile" world, Jon leaves the compound and moves in with Abigail, who makes a home for those who, like herself, have left Unity. Jon is confused by the outside world, yet hopeful first. But as reality slaps him, he realizes he has no foundation to complete his education, he can't cope with so much ambiguity, and the news that Celeste is now married to and pregnant by his father stings. In the second part of the book, Jon spins out of control, turning to drink and drugs, until he manages to find purpose. Several of the characters are one-dimensional, including Jon's greatest champion, but the story propels readers and gives them insight into the appeal of lives where decisions are made for you.
Kirkus Reviews
After being caught kissing a girl, 17-year-old Jon leaves Unity, the faith-based polygamous community in which they were both born and raised.Though Jon's departure is abrupt, it's not unexpected: According to the Prophet, a man must have at least three wives to get into heaven, and there simply aren't enough women to go around. Jon is not the first boy to leave Unity: There are several lost boys living in a nearby city who have found shelter with Abigail, a former Unity resident dedicated to helping these runaways build new lives. With Abigail's support, Jon gets a construction job and a tutor. First-person present-tense narration conveys Jon's initial bewilderment with mainstream social norms, encouraging readers' reflection and compassion as he struggles to navigate the outside world. The pacing is uneven, skipping chunks of time as Jon's life unravels while he grows frustrated by his slow progress in school and drops out. While the story is educational, Jon's narration in the second half of the book as he encounters many aspects of modern life for the first time—from salt-and-vinegar potato chips to the wonders of the internet—often feels self-conscious and overtly didactic in a way that may not engage readers. Major characters present as white.This companion novel to Sister Wife (2008) ends on a hopeful note for the young people of Unity struggling to make sense of the world beyond. (Fiction. 13-18)