ALA Booklist (Mon Jul 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)

Skye believed moving would change everything, but it has only made her sister, Deirdre, more isolated as Skye tries to put her past behind her. When they were younger, the sisters were extremely close, often playing fantasy make-believe games Deirdre would create. Skye was the Queen of Swords, Deirdre's protector, a role she almost took too far one day. In their new home, Deirdre continues to withdraw into her fantasy world, spending hours playing in the wooded swamps in their backyard, until the night she disappears. Torn between grief and jealousy at wanting to live her own life, Skye is determined to bring Deirdre home. Unfortunately for her, Deirdre's new fantastical world blurs the lines of reality and may have awoken real monsters living in the woods nsters that want to play a game and demand sacrifices to advance. Bérubé has written a horror story that is part demented Bridge to Terabithia and part folktale the Pear Drum. Readers will never see the end coming. Give to teens who want brutally honest stories without fairy tale happy endings.

Kirkus Reviews

A creepy, insidious tale that shows how treacherous a sister's attachment can be.After a move, two teenage sisters find themselves in a new home on the edge of the woods, where Skye branches out while introspective Deirdre finds solace playing games her sister no longer has patience for. When Deirdre vanishes, Skye is forced to reexamine the past choices she made to protect her sister and must decide if she will face the grim, irreversible consequences of saving Deirdre again. These memories form a haunting exposition that Bérubé (The Dark Beneath the Ice, 2018) uses in conjunction with the plot to covertly insert suspense. They are so seamlessly executed that readers can forget whether they are in Skye's past or present world. This does conjure up some confusion but also creates an immersive, nuanced world and characters who can't be labeled as merely "good" or "bad." Three section breaks named after different characters have lush illustrations of flora and fauna and lines quoting poet Gwendolyn McEwen that act as an aesthetic backdrop to the actual story; each is narrated from Skye's first-person perspective. All characters default to white.For those who are not faint of heart, morally or otherwise, and who wish to sink into an intricate, subtle, and deeply unsettling read. (Horror. 14-18)

School Library Journal (Thu Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)

Gr 9 Up--Skye is 16 years old and is tired of playing childish games with her younger sister, Deirdre. After moving, Skye starts to make new friends and start a new life, while Deirdre lives in the past in her fantasy world, building creatures in the woods. One night, Deirdre disappears from their home and the search for her begins. Then one of Deirdre's homemade monsters visits Skye and tells her how to get Deirdre back. Can she do it? This book is reminiscent of Katherine Paterson's Bridge to Terabithia, with much darker undertones. Both Skye and Deirdre are a little difficult to relate toDeirdre isolates herself, while Skye at first seems indifferent to the fact that her sister is missing. That aside, the action starts right away and quickly draws readers into the story. Teens will be kept guessing what is real and what is imagined by these sisters who couldn't be more different. VERDICT This book, dark and eerie with just the right amount of creepiness, is perfect for any fan of young adult horror. -Maeve Dodds, Charlotte Mecklenburg Library, NC