ALA Booklist (Wed Jul 06 00:00:00 CDT 2022)

It's impossible to read Galchen's novel without being reminded of Norton Juster's The Phantom Tollbooth. It revels in wordplay and the off-kilter logic that governs the fantastic land that Fred, a nearly 13-year-old girl, enters by stepping through a giant paper lantern in pursuit of her mother. She is inconveniently deposited in a dungeon with a sullen elephant named Downer, who gives Fred the delightfully strange lowdown on her new locale. This is the Land of Impossibility, governed by the Rat Queen (currently imprisoned herself), who banned timekeeping, getting older, and the very mention of birthday parties, otherwise known as "The Essential and Very Good and No One Can Disagree with Rat Rule 79." The pair is serendipitously freed by Gogo the mongoose, and they band together to rescue the queen and find Fred's mom. It is an immensely imaginative, mind-bending journey that explores dealing with change and growing up. Short, creatively titled chapters feature line drawings and lovely illustrations in red and black. Galchen's first book for children is full of heart and celebrates unconventional thinking.

Kirkus Reviews (Wed Jul 06 00:00:00 CDT 2022)

The day before Fred's 13th birthday, she enters a magical world on an adventure that pays homage to classic children's fantasy.Fred and her mother have moved four times in six years, and Fred is frankly sick and tired of it. Angry at her mom though she may be, however, when Fred sees her mother step into an enormous paper lantern and vanish, she still plunges to the rescue. So it is that this young white girl finds herself locked in a dungeon with an elephant called Downer, in a land where much is illegal under "THE ESSENTIAL AND VERY GOOD AND NO ONE CAN DISAGREE WITH RAT RULE 79": no keeping time, no getting older or wiser, and absolutely no birthday parties. Also no peanut butter. Downer wants to rescue the Rat Queen, Fred wants to rescue her mother, and a mongoose named Gogo needs to earn money to take care of her 17 children. The Land of Impossibility (depicted incompletely on a "topo-illogical" map) is a metaphor-heavy dreamscape evocative of The Phantom Tollbooth, while its magical animals speak with a combination of pedantry and nonsense paralleling that found in Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. Two-color illustrations similarly evoke historical styles. Snarky cleverness and famous paradoxes charm, but they are weakened by too-quick resolutions to both major and minor plot threads. Troublingly, a character's depression is treated as a matter of personal choice.High nonsense that almost lives up to its potential—but not quite. (Fantasy. 9-11)

School Library Journal (Wed Jul 06 00:00:00 CDT 2022)

Gr 4 Up-- Fred is sick of moving. Her math professor mother has moved them to five places in the last six years. On the eve of her 13th birthday, Fred's lack of friends to celebrate with has made her angrier than usual. After storming off to her room, she is surprised when time passes without her mother coming to check on her. When she goes to investigate, she sees her mother dressed for a party and standing in front of a giant paper lanternwhich she then walks into and disappears. Fred makes the momentous decision to follow her, and thus begins her journey in the land of impossibility. Following in the tradition of many nonsense tales, adventures ensue as Fred meets Downer, a depressed elephant, and a truculent mongoose named Gogo. Together they help Fred navigate a world where time is outlawed and residents live by the rules of the mysterious Rat Queen. Fred and her friends encounter a variety of odd creatures as they struggle to solve a riddle that could be the ultimate solution to their varying problems. A consistently droll tone carries the story along. Math and math-inspired tales are threaded throughout, along with amusing word play and many a meta moment. Megalos's intricate illustrations lend beauty and expression to the story, offering a much-needed connection to the strange characters and setting. VERDICT Loopy, confusing, and in love with its own cleverness, this story occasionally feels like a slog and may appeal more to adults in search of a nostalgic read. Give to dedicated fans of classic novels like Norton Juster's The Phantom Tollbooth , L. Frank Baum's The Wonderful Wizard of Oz , and Lewis Carroll's Alice's Adventures in Wonderland . A secondary purchase for most libraries.-Kristy Pasquariello, Westwood Public Library, MA