ALA Booklist
(Tue Jan 03 00:00:00 CST 2023)
Seven Salazar is a Witchling who is excited to be placed in a coven and come into her full powers during the approaching Black Moon Ceremony; so it's a devastating shock when the big day comes and Seven is instead made a "Spare" with two other girls. Determined to cast off this undesirable fate, the three girls undertake an impossible task so that they might become fully fledged witches in a coven of their own making t they will have to work together if they are to succeed. Ortega (Ghost Squad, 2020) weaves a gorgeous tale of determination and magic in her sophomore novel. The story explores the importance of having understanding and supportive friends, especially while making personal discoveries and finding out what one is really made of. This touching tale blends fantastic and realistic moments to create a saga of sisterhood that will resonate with readers even as it charms. Pair this with Emma Steinkellner's The Okay Witch (2019) and Julie Abe's Eva Evergreen, Semi-Magical Witch (2020).
Kirkus Reviews
(Tue Jan 03 00:00:00 CST 2023)
It's the night of the Black Moon Ceremony, when Witchlings in Ravenskill are assigned to their covens, and the one thing 12-year-old Seven Salazar hopes to avoid is being made a Spare Witch.When her fears unfortunately come to pass, she's faced with two other leftover and unlikely new companions-not to mention a challenge that might just prove deadly. Alongside the other Spares, anxious Thorn La Roux and bully Valley Pepperhorn, Seven must embark on a dangerous quest to find and kill the rumored child-eating Nightbeast. Through their adventures, however, Seven learns about a lot more than just the mystery of the Nightbeast: She comes to see people-including herself-differently. She peers beneath her first assumptions and stands up for others even when that's not easy. When she fears a friend is experiencing parental abuse, she brings her concerns to an adult she trusts even though she's frightened it will make her friend angry. The story balances serious social themes with lighthearted friendship hijinks, and the plot is fast-paced and full of gratifying twists. Ortega invites readers in, combining familiar fantasy furnishings with a low-key, modern-inflected tone. Seven is cued as Latine, and many of the spells she invokes on her journey ring with Spanish roots, offering Spanish speakers the joy of recognition and others the excitement of new-forged understanding. Thorn and Valley read as White.Energetic and intelligent; invites readers to question their assumptions and the status quo. (Fantasy. 8-12)
School Library Journal
(Tue Jan 03 00:00:00 CST 2023)
Gr 37 Twelve-year-old Seven Salazar excitedly awaits the Black Moon ceremony where she and her best friend Poppy hope to be placed in the powerful coven, House Hyacinth. Sadly, only Poppy joins House Hyacinth and in a nightmare come true, Seven finds out that she's a Spare. In the magical town of Ravenskill, Spares are looked down on and have less power. To make matters worse, also in her coven are Seven's bully, Valley Pepperhorn, and a girl named Thorn. When the three are unable to seal their coven, Seven invokes the impossible task which, if completed successfully, would seal their coven and give them their full power as witches. Their impossible task to fell the Nightbeast is a difficult enough endeavor, but they also have to contend with their constant bickering, the community's unfavorable view toward Spares, and a mysterious conspiracy surrounding the Nightbeast. The trio of witchlings eventually overcome misunderstandings, grow to trust each other, and work together. The sorting system has a unique spin to it with the presence and treatment of the Spares. Readers familiar with Spanish may recognize the magic words used to cast spells: viento for wind, esconder for hiding something, and so on. Among the cast are many Latinx characters, a character with a nonbinary gender identity, and those in a same-sex relationship. The poor treatment of Spares may spark a timely conversation on the lack of protection for marginalized communities. The witchlings also find out that Valley's father is abusive, on one occasion starving her for two days because of a bad grade. Mentions of abuse may be distressing to some readers. VERDICT A magic-filled quest of friendship and power sure to please lovers of the genre; an excellent purchase for libraries.Myiesha Speight