Perma-Bound Edition ©2023 | -- |
Publisher's Hardcover ©2021 | -- |
Paperback ©2023 | -- |
Eleven-year-old Maple Mehta-Cohen loves words.She loves hearing her father read books aloud to her before bedtime, and she loves dictating her own stories into the digital voice recorder that she keeps in her pocket at all times-she dreams up mysteries about a sleuth called Mira Epstein-Patel. Maybe that's why it took until fifth grade for a teacher to finally notice that Maple has serious struggles with reading. After screening tests reveal that she exhibits characteristics of dyslexia, Maple learns that, unlike her best friends, she is going to have to repeat the fifth grade. Although her friends assure her that nothing has to change between them, on the first day of school, they ignore her. In her new fifth grade classroom, Maple tries to connect with people, but her attempts are tripped up by her embarrassment, and she lies about why she's been held back. Struggling with her friendships and her self-esteem, Maple wonders who she's become-and how she can get back to being her old self, a person that she once truly loved. Maple's narratorial voice is frank and quirky, and her journey with coming to terms with her learning disability is layered, believable, and well researched. Maple has a White Jewish mother and an Indian father who coined the term Hin-Jew to describe her. The book repeatedly references her Indian identity, but her Jewish side is less developed.A layered, utterly readable novel about a biracial protagonist grappling with dyslexia. (Fiction. 8-12)
School Library Journal (Mon Jun 05 00:00:00 CDT 2023)Gr 4-7 Maple Mehta-Cohen has a secret, and she has worked hard to make sure no one finds out. Maple loves to tell, and spends much of her time dictating, her stories about her half-Indian, half-Jewish sleuth into her recorder. But despite her storytelling ability and expansive vocabulary, Maple doesn't know how to read. Her teacher thought it best for Maple to repeat fifth grade so that she can get help with reading. But Maple is not sure about this plan. It means leaving her two best friends, Aislinn and Marigold, and having everyone wonder why she is still in fifth grade. When the school year starts, things aren't better. Maple's teacher asks her to help new kid Jack learn his way around the school, plus she must go to Ms. Fine's groupthe one that is for students who can't read. When Jack asks why Maple is still in fifth grade, the lies start, and Maple isn't sure she can stop. She is caught telling stories to her new friends in her reading group, trying to keep her old friends who don't seem to want to spend time with a fifth-grader, and staying true to herself. Though poignant, with so many different things happening, the novel doesn't really get to the depth of Maple's reading struggles, or her issues with friends, leaving the ending feeling unresolved. VERDICT For young people who struggle with reading or feeling different because of other academic issues, Maple is a welcome protagonist. Rebekah Buchanan, Western Illinois Univ., Macomb
Kirkus Reviews (Mon Jun 05 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
School Library Journal (Mon Jun 05 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
Normally, I'm not a morning person.
On normal mornings, Dad has to wake me for school. "Maaaaaple. Rise and shine," he says in a whisper at first. Then, when I barely stir, he says it again, louder.
"Miss Maple, rise and shine! Places to go, people to see!"
Mom says I was always like this, even as a baby, even though most babies are awake and screaming at five a.m. "We used to have to wake you for day care," she says, shrugging. "You were a sleeper."
Not today, though. Today, my nerves are buzzing like an alarm clock. My eyelids don't even feel heavy.
From one of my bedroom windows, I have a beautiful view of a garage wall. It belongs to the next-door neighbors, who don't even have a car anyway. They just use it to store things--air conditioners and bicycles they don't ride, boxes of old books, toys their son has long outgrown. There's nothing very useful about that view.
From my other window, though, I can see sky. Just a sliver, because that's what you get when you live on the first floor in a city, surrounded by other houses and garages and a few scraggly trees. But it's enough sky to tell me things about the day ahead.
Today, the sky is the darkest blue a sky can ever be, the color that only appears in the short time between night and day. When it's no longer yesterday but it's barely today. It's just right now. I wish it could stay right now forever, so I wouldn't have to live through the rest of today.
Because today is the first day of fifth grade. Again.
Chapter 2
"We're holding Maple back."
Those were the four little words that ruined my life.
It was last April. Ms. Littleton-Chan called a meeting with my parents and me. She said it was "quite important," and my mouth was already dry when we sat down in front of her desk. I'd never had a "quite important" meeting with my parents and a teacher before.
Look, under normal circumstances, I love Ms. Littleton-Chan. Last year was her first year teaching at the Barton, and she was different from all the other teachers I'd ever had. I loved her right away, from the first day of fifth grade. It wasn't just because she also has a bicultural last name, although I appreciate that. It matches my Indian-Jewish hyphenated situation (Hin-Jew, my parents call me). More than that, it was that she seemed so interested in all the things she taught us. Like when we did a unit on ocean ecosystems, she could barely contain herself telling us about how the blue whale eats up to 40 million krill per day. Those are like little shrimp. Forty million shrimp! I'm telling you, she was practically levitating with enthusiasm. Ms. Littleton-Chan cares about things, about us, in a way that felt new. She notices things.
Which, in retrospect, might be why she was the first person to notice the real me. The me I'd been hiding in big and small ways, every day, since I don't remember when.
I can't read.
Or, I mean, I can't really read. Not well. Not easily. Here's what it feels like to look at a page in a book, if you're me: Some of the letters look sideways or upside down. Sometimes the letters flip around. Or they swim around on the page and won't stay still long enough for me to grab them with my brain. There might be a picture of a dog and I know the word should say dog, but I'm looking at it and it says odg. So I can read it, kind of, but it's confusing. And if the word odg is next to a picture of, like, a cat or a rainbow, then I'm extra confused. And on their own, the words look less like sentences and more like a puzzle. A whole page is like an ocean. When I look at it, I feel like I'm drowning. I can swim really, really slowly. But it hurts my brain to try.
When I hear a story out loud, I understand everything. But when I have to read to myself, it all goes out of whack. I can sound words out, sure. But it takes me a long time. Too long. So long that by the time I get to the end of a sentence, I've practically forgotten what happened at the beginning. It's hard to put it all together. It's frustrating to spend that much time on what seems so easy to everyone else. I usually just give up.
Up until Ms. Littleton-Chan came along, I kept it a secret. We almost always work in groups at my school, and I'm really good at looking at other people's papers without looking like I'm looking. Or when we talk about the book we're reading, I'll listen for a while, and then add an idea that builds on someone else's.
But Ms. Littleton-Chan watched us carefully. She saw us. And with those four words--"We're holding Maple back"--my love for her exploded like sodium when it hits water. (Which, by the way, I learned about in fourth grade from Mr. Nolan. I don't need Ms. Littleton-Chan for everything.)
"We're holding Maple back."
To my left, Mom shifted in her chair. "Sorry, what do you mean?"
Ms. Littleton-Chan looked uncomfortable. She observed both my parents, and then her eyes landed on me. "Maple, have you told your parents what happens when you look at a book?"
My parents' heads swiveled in my direction. I shrugged.
"Maple, what's going on?" Dad looked concerned. He'd been up late working; I could tell from the way his face was all dark shadows and deep creases. Besides, when I got up to pee, I saw the light on in the kitchen. He always works in the kitchen at night, hunched over his sketch pad or pounding on his laptop keys, crunching numbers and keeping his business running. My parents are both artists. They work really hard at it. My dad has his own company, putting his custom designs on T-shirts and baseball caps and phone cases and basically anything you can imagine. My mom designs jewelry. She's kind of famous. The mayor once wore one of Mom's necklaces at a building dedication.
"You can tell us, kid," Dad said. "Anything."
But I couldn't. I couldn't explain why I wasn't able to make sense of the words on a page in front of me, because I didn't even understand it myself. The thing is, I love books. I love books when Dad reads aloud to me in bed, even though eleven is maybe too old to be reading in bed with your father. I love the way books look on my shelves, and the way they feel in my hands. I love the way the pages smell.
Most of all, I love stories. I'm constantly telling them in my head. I'll get an idea for a story, and it'll be running through my brain, no matter what else I'm doing. I'll even tell myself stories out loud sometimes. For my tenth birthday, my parents gave me a digital voice recorder. It's a little machine I can keep in my pocket and use to document my stories, anywhere, anytime. I'll pop it out of my pocket, hit record, and just start talking.
Which is convenient, because actually writing my stories down on paper . . . That part is harder for me than anyone knows. My parents included.
"I don't know," I said finally. That was the truth. More or less.
"What do you mean, you don't know?" Mom said. She sounded frantic.
"Honey." Dad reached over me and put a hand on Mom's knee. "We'll figure this out."
Ms. Littleton-Chan cleared her throat. "Maple, listen. You're an exceptionally smart girl. You're curious and persistent. You're creative. You're kind to your classmates."
I started feeling a little indignant at that point. (Have I mentioned that I know a lot of long words? Dad is always explaining the long words to me when we listen to the radio, and I never forget what they mean. Indignant means feeling or showing annoyance at what is perceived as unfair treatment. Which sounds about right at the moment.) I am curious and persistent and kind. I was ready for sixth grade!
Technically, fifth grade is our last year of elementary school. Even though they're in the same building, the sixth, seventh, and eighth grades are considered the middle school. And two other elementary schools also send their kids to the Barton Middle School, so the middle-school grades are bigger. They even switch classes for math and English, and go on an overnight trip to New York in the spring. It's major. I had plans for all this with Marigold Harris and Aislinn McIntyre, my best friends since day care and first grade, respectively.
"We need to make sure your reading skills are ready before we send you on to the next grade." Ms. Littleton-Chan turned back to my parents. "The longer we let Maple go without addressing her reading fluency, the more learning she's going to miss. And it's not just English class she'll miss out on--it's math and science and history. I don't want that. Do you, Maple?"
It felt like a trick question. Of course I didn't want to miss those things, did I? But wasn't this kind of, like, the school's fault? They're the ones who let me down, and now I was getting punished for it. I bit my lip and kept quiet.
"It wouldn't be responsible of me to send Maple to sixth grade right now," Ms. Littleton-Chan continued. Apparently, there was still more to say. "Her reading skills aren't ready for middle school yet or for everything that comes next. The pace of the work really picks up from now on. Maple, I just don't want you to be left behind. If we keep you in fifth another year, we can get your reading challenges sorted out. Then you'll really be ready to soar."
Excerpted from Welcome Back, Maple Mehta-Cohen by Kate McGovern
All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.
“Adventure abounds and develops into a solid story for students who struggle with reading. . . . This is a story to share with all.” —School Library Connection (starred review)
Maple Mehta-Cohen has a secret: she can’t read very well. She has an impressive vocabulary and loves dictating stories into her recorder—especially the adventures of a daring sleuth who’s half Indian and half Jewish like Maple herself—but words on the page just don’t seem to make sense to her. Despite all Maple’s clever tricks, her teacher is on to her, and now Maple has to repeat fifth grade. Maple is devastated—what will her friends think? So she uses her storytelling skills to convince her classmates that she’s staying back as a special teacher’s assistant. But as Maple navigates the loss of old friendships, the possibility of new ones, and her reading challenges head-on, her deception becomes harder to keep up. Can Maple begin to recognize her own strengths and love herself—and her brain—just the way she is? In a paperback edition with an eye-catching cover, this heartwarming story and its bright, creative heroine will have special appeal to readers who have faced their own trials with school and friendships.