ALA Booklist
(Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
A murky, atmospheric prologue reveals a primordial conflict between good and evil that leaves an artifact behind for the present day, the present day where readers find Haru, a flightless and bullied blue bird that a dark force believes to be the chosen one. Haru and their piglet friend Yama stumble upon the Heart of Briar, a hideously powerful and dangerous object that must be destroyed. While their Tolkienian quest merely begins in this volume, they encounter friends and enemies and must traverse a moody, rundown shopping mall, an unusual locale for epic fantasy which, along with the school-based social issues and the colloquial language, makes for a distinctive, grounded mixture that could prove enticing to genre neophytes. As well, this early segment of the journey hinges less on action and more on characters overcoming dark inner voices, voices of uncertainty, anger, and inadequacy. The art comes in muted, earthy tones, and the characters occupy soft, rounded bodies, as though they and their world are shaped of clay, still searching for their final form.
School Library Journal
(Fri Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2024)
Gr 4–6— Haru is a small blue bird who lives in the forest with their little sibling Goose and their mom, who is a ghost. Haru dreams of leaving the forest but can't fly. Schoolmates make fun of them (their words "sting like paper cuts"), but they do have a best friend—a small pig called Yama. When an evil "heart of briar" finds Yama, and Yama can't get rid of it, the friends ask a wise oak tree for advice, and soon, they set off on their quest to The Beacon ("we're never alone as long as we have each other"). Their journey is full of danger: the heart of briar has a negative effect on Yama, and Haru faces a creature of darkness and death called Blight, but comes through unscathed by holding fast to their inner light. Meanwhile, Goose and his friend Frei, a firefly, follow Haru's trail while Herb, a sentient mushroomlike figure they meet along the way, helps as much as they can. The ending is left to be resolved in further volumes, with Haru and Yama continuing their journey, Goose in danger, and Herb regretful that they couldn't help more. The themes and artistic style call to mind books like Ben Hatke's Things in the Basement and T. Probert's Lightfall . VERDICT Good-hearted Haru is a character to root for in this often-dark beginning, leavened with moments of humor. Recommended where graphic novel fantasy is popular.— Jenny Arch