Kirkus Reviews
Goth teen Corinth meets a fierce and curious mermaid in this retelling of "The Little Mermaid."High schooler Corinth lives in a seaside town and has loving parents, including a Deaf mom with whom she signs, but no real friends outside of her emotionally abusive boyfriend, Seth. One day, while cleaning up garbage on the beach, Corinth is pulled under the water by a mysterious blue mermaid, whom she soon befriends. The two become very close-close enough that mermaid Skylla decides to use dangerous magic to become human so she can be with Corinth. Corinth and Seth appear White; in her human form, Skylla has light-brown skin and wavy brown hair. Corinth is short and curvy, while Skylla is tall and muscular. The art style is cute and colorful, and the mermaid's design is pleasingly piscine. This offering is successful as a fairy-tale retelling, keeping the original's major beats but fleshing out the modern characters and their world, making it feel fresh. This is clearly a love story but without a romantic kiss and featuring the liberal use of the word friend to describe the relationship between the female leads. Some readers may find this disappointing, while others may appreciate that the love between Skylla and Corinth does not require typical romantic labels.An endearing book that is simultaneously fun and moving. (Graphic fantasy. 13-18)
School Library Journal
(Wed Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2023)
Gr 6–9— Beach cleaning is a way to pass the time for 15-year-old Corinth, new to town and friendless except for rocker boyfriend, Seth. Despite a warning that people have disappeared from the beach, Corinth is drawn to the shore by a siren's call and pulled underwater. Dazzled by Corinth's pendant, the teeth-baring mermaid delivers the dazed girl back to shore, thus beginning a friendship between the two. Corinth teaches the mermaid to communicate using ASL, vocalization, and books on mythology, and the mermaid picks the name Skylla to use between them. As the friendship grows, conflicts arise. Seth is a domineering and possessive bully; Skylla is challenged by her sisters, who fight in acts of dominance and tests of strength. Wishing to remain on land, Skylla appeals to her magical ancestors for a transformation spell, but the spell comes with a terrible price. This graphic novel retelling of "The Little Mermaid" mirrors the original's themes of transformation, empowerment, and discerning real love from obsession, as Corinth begins to understand how Seth's actions reflect an escalating abuse cycle. Through self-awareness, Corinth and Skylla find agency and acceptance and escape abuse. Corinth's expressive eyes lend a charming, empathic quality to the relatable protagonist, who speaks in sign language with her Deaf mother. A cliffhanger ending suggests a second installment may reveal if Corinth and Skylla's friendship can weather the forecasted storm. VERDICT A recommended selection for summer reading; this graphic novel can be paired with the original text and other fantastical versions of Anderson's classic cautionary tale.— Rebecca Jung