Horn Book
With Paul Mantell. Excitement reigns at Hidden Valley Junior High with the football team's state championship game approaching. In their fourth book, ninth-grade twins Tiki and Ronde are playing their best until chicken pox sidelines them. Despite the heavily laid-on message about teamwork making victory possible, the story will appeal to sports enthusiasts and fans of the real-life NFL brothers.
ALA Booklist
In the fourth book of the football series that began with Kickoff (2007), the Eagles junior-high team struggles through the playoffs as the players battle their community's high expectations as well as chicken pox. Twins Tiki and Ronde each miss a game, but team members step up when the Eagles take the field, eventually playing in the state championship. Like the earlier books, this one emphasizes good values and teamwork on and off the field, but readers who come to the book looking for play-by-play football action will find plenty here, beginning with Kadir Nelson's cover illustration.
Kirkus Reviews
There's no modesty going to waste here as the Barber twins star as themselves in another in their series of football hero tales. Here, Tiki and Ronde are eighth graders hoping for a run to the state championships. However, football fever has hit Hidden Valley Junior High School—literally, in the form of chicken pox—and when players start coming down with the pox, Tiki and Ronde fear the worst: If they get sick, what will the team do without its best athletes? Along with the usual sports messages of teamwork, hard work, keeping the faith, dreams and picking yourself up when you don't succeed, the novel adds didacticism and narcissism to the mix. Still, lots of football action, an exuberant use of exclamation points and a plot that runs like a footrace for the end zone will keep credulous young readers flying through the pages. And with ninth grade still ahead for the Barbers, more volumes are likely in the works. (Fiction. 8-12)